top of page

Having it all: but at what cost?

Writer: Dra. Martina Goldsztein
Dra. Martina Goldsztein
21 hours ago
3 min read

Collab: Martina Goldsztein. Lawyer specialized in Environmental and Administrative Law. Honorary lecturer at the University of Buenos Aires (UBA). Founder of Ambiental & +.


The paradox of “Resource-Rich” countries.

Latin America is home to an abundance of natural resources: forests minerals water fertile land and extensive oil reserves. However having access to so many resources doesn't always translate into better living conditions for the people who inhabit these territories. How is it possible that regions so rich in natural resources coexist with inequality social conflict and environmental degradation?.

One possible explanation lies in the widely discussed concept of the “extractivist model” which is based on the intensive extraction of natural resources primarily for export often with little processing taking place within the country itself. While these activities can generate revenue investment and jobs they also raise important questions about how the benefits are distributed and who ultimately bears the costs.

This is where the concept of “neo-extractivism” comes into play. It refers to an approach to natural resource extraction in which the state plays a more active role both in promoting and regulating these activities. Although historically associated with progressive governments in Latin America intensive resource extraction remains a central topic of debate under different political approaches. Today Argentina Colombia and Brazil offer different political contexts, with governments representing different ideological perspectives. This leads us to ask: to what extent do changes in government also bring changes in development models and in the way countries relate to their natural resources?

And here we come to a central issue: it is not only about which resources are extracted but also how they are extracted who benefits from them and what consequences they bring.

Having natural resources does not necessarily mean achieving development. A territory may contribute enormous quantities of raw materials to the national economy and international trade but this doesn't guarantee that its inhabitants will have access to better public services infrastructure or living conditions. In fact the opposite can happen: the communities living closest to extractive projects may also be the ones who bear most of their negative impacts.

For me the consequences of extractivism go far beyond its immediate environmental impact. From an economic perspective exporting raw materials can be an important source of revenue investment and job creation. However it also presents the challenge of diversifying economies adding value to natural resources within each country and avoiding excessive dependence on international markets. From a social perspective extractive projects can create job opportunities and stimulate local economies but their impact on communities Indigenous peoples rights and traditional ways of life must also be taken into account. At the territorial level the development of large-scale projects can reshape regional organization productive activities and the everyday dynamics of the populations living there.

Added to these challenges are environmental concerns such as deforestation soil degradation pollution and intensive water use. For this reason it is essential to examine how these activities are planned what monitoring and regulatory mechanisms are in place and how both their benefits and potential negative impacts are distributed.

One case that helps us understand these tensions is Ecuador's "Yusuní-ITT Initiative" launched in 2007. The proposal was to leave the oil reserves underground in exchange for financial contributions from the international community. Its main goals were to prevent greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions protect Yasuní National Park and safeguard the communities living in the area. In 2013 due to a lack of international funding the Ecuadorian government officially ended the initiative and authorized oil extraction to move forward. However the debate continued. Ten years later in August 2023 a national referendum was held and voters decided that oil extraction in Block 43-ITT should be stopped and the oil left underground. This case shows that decisions about natural resources involve much more than economic considerations: they also put ecosystem conservation community rights and citizen participation at stake.

Thinking about alternative development models means finding ways to use natural resources more efficiently and responsibly. The transition towards SCP (Sustainable Consumption and Production) aims to move in this direction through more efficient use of materials and energy the promotion of a circular economy, and greater consideration of environmental and social impacts throughout production processes. The challenge isn't necessarily to stop using natural resources but rather to find ways of doing so that take into account people's needs and the limits of ecosystems. So having it all but at what cost? At the cost of pursuing a development model that if it fails to consider its consequences can put territories ecosystems and the opportunities of future generations at risk. The real opportunity lies in transforming this natural wealth into collective well-being. Because development shouldn't be measured only by what we are capable of extracting, but also by what we are capable of preserving and building. Thinking about development also means thinking about the world we want to create #ForABetterWorld.

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.

Thank you! :)

"Música por un mundo mejor"Miguel Lorena Group
00:00 / 04:18
  • Whatsapp
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook

"Let us not tire of doing good"

© 2021 Created by Environmental & + - Copyright - Copyright A&+ - Martina Goldsztein.

bottom of page